Topic: can send mail, can not receive mail.

==== Required information ====
- iRedMail version:
- Store mail accounts in which backend (LDAP/MySQL/PGSQL):
- Linux/BSD distribution name and version:
- Related log if you're reporting an issue:

I'm using version 8.4 on debian 7 with a sql backend.

Our mx handles several email accounts using multiple domain names.  One particular domain name isn't working with email.  From the johncenamail.com domain, and email address associated with it can send, however it cannot receive.  Any time an email is sent to the problem domain from an outside service provider such as gmail, yahoo, and zoho... we get a service delayed message like so:

This message was created automatically by mail delivery system.



The original message was received at Wed, 27 Mar 2013 11:33:58 -0700
from validemail@zoho.com [validemail@zoho.com]

    ----- The following addresses had fatal errors -----   
   [Status: Error, Address: <brad@johncenamail.com>, ResponseCode 421, , Host not reachable.]

Message will be retried for 4 more day(s)

Thinking my dns is wrong, I decided to use a web based dig service to check.  I will use the acutal address here to help in troubleshooting.  First, I wanted to see the mx record for johncenamail.com.  I used http://mxtoolbox.com/
It reports the correct mx for johncenamail.com.  I then used the same website to see if mx.joplinservers.com resolves to the correct IP, and that is fine as well.  Email accounts using other domains can send and receive fine, so obviously the firewall is not an issue as well as the server's ability to send and receive in general.

Out of curiosity, I wanted to see if the problem domain can receive emails from other domains hosted on the same server.  This does indeed work.  It's not simply because the DNS is answering it's own querries either, because the above website also reports the intended information... and when I dig and ping from my personal computer, it matches exactly the website information.  My personal computer uses different DNS's than the server... along with being on a different ISP's network.

Thinking this may be a classic case of DNS caching, I put this problem on the back burner... TWO WEEKS ago.  Any cache/ttl's should have expired long ago.

I'm puzzeled.  Any suggestions would be very much appreciated.


Re: can send mail, can not receive mail.

brad.b82 wrote:

----- The following addresses had fatal errors -----   
[Status: Error, Address: <brad@johncenamail.com>, ResponseCode 421, , Host not reachable.]

Looks like caused by greylisting, you can temporarily turn off greylisting for testing. Steps to disable greylisting on Debian 7:

*) Open /etc/cluebringer/cluebringer.conf, find below line:


*) Set 'enabled=1' to 'enabled=0' to disable greylisting:


*) Restart cluebringer service:

# /etc/init.d/postfix-cluebringer restart

Then try again.


Does my reply help a little? How about buying me a cup of coffee ($5) as an encouragement?

buy me a cup of coffee


Re: can send mail, can not receive mail.

hi all,
i have the same problem with iRedMail 0.8.4 MYSQL and Debian 7.0
i have disabled greylisting but don't solve the problem!!
the strange scene is that i can't receive any error message from gmail or other provider when i send email....

i hope to solve this problem!!



Re: can send mail, can not receive mail.

hi Zhang,
i have solved the problems...

clients have set wrong ip on dns server!! smile